← All Articles
ARTICLE

Why Deacons? Can Women Be Priests?

The stained-glass ceiling is broken.

DR. KLUANE SPAKE

Why Only Deacons?

On Friday, Pope Francis said the Vatican would study the possibility of ordaining Catholic women as deacons, as part of the church’s efforts to give a greater leadership role to women.

Certainly the question should be: WHY DEACONS? Can women be priests?

Both Catholics and many Protestants continue to suppress women by using terms like “keys,” “ruling authority,” and “God’s order of creation.” They teach their determination to preserve the patriarchal order. Some groups (you’ve probably heard them) herald the slogan, “Man first, but for the right reason!” As though hypnotized, many blindly repeat this claim without substantiation. They say that man unconditionally carries the role of ruling, while the woman gets the “beautiful task” of supporting.

The Four Main Hindrances for Catholics Not Ordaining Women
  • Natural condition of inferiority of their gender because of the Fall.
  • The scriptural need for them to be kept in subjection.
  • Biological fact of menstruation (uncleanness).
  • Lack of external male genitalia.

The Vatican declaration of 1976 concluded that women can’t be ordained as priests because:

“There must be a physical resemblance between the priest and Christ. The possession of male genitalia becomes the essential prerequisite for representing Christ, who in his maleness is the disclosure in earthly culture of the male God. The celibacy of the priest, confirming the celibacy of Jesus, links both to a realm distant from that of nature, embodiment, and the reproduction of women.”

This declaration later states that women are incapable of receiving the “indelible character” of male reproductive organs necessary to handle ministry.

We Are ALL Priests Already!

Surely we must understand: all believers are PRIESTS already! We are a HOLY priesthood (1 Pet. 2:5, 9). Believers are called to be kings and priests and heirs to the Kingdom (Rev. 1:6). No man can give that priesthood to us.

My Day at the Vatican

During a visit to Rome some years ago, I received a divine plan…

I stood in an exquisite older hotel room, ironing my clothes for dinner, when I heard the Lord speak to me. Overwhelmed with the gravity of this instruction, I said, “Okay, Lord! I’ll do it!”

As soon as I said these words, the plug from the iron (plugged into a socket in the old light fixture over my head) came out. The wire dropped down the side of my body, sparking and sizzling all the way down. When it hit the floor, there was a HUGE explosion! The power went out in the hotel for hours.

Then I knew that it was for this moment that I was born. No opposition could change my mind. “I WILL do it.” I made the plan and packed a little bag.

Suddenly, a stranger knocked on my hotel door. She said her name was Helen, and that the Lord told her to come help me… with whatever it was.

I asked her to come with me to the Vatican. It was very crowded that day as we went to Saint Peter’s. We prayed that we would be hidden in God’s quiver and that no one would see us.

We walked through the crowds and the guards, up to the canopy where the pope and other priests stand to minister. No guards saw me. No one in the crowd stopped me… I slipped past the red velvet ropes and over to the vestibule. I boldly climbed the stairs and stood behind the pulpit, where the pope stands. Helen stood at the bottom of the stairs.

From the pulpit, I loudly declared, “I am a PROPHET, PRIEST, and KING.” Turning around, I said it over and over. “I take my place. I stand here for all women.”

Then I read the Biblical promises of coming unity in the Body of Christ, and declared the hidden things that would now become manifest.

In my little bag were wine, a tiny glass, and bread. And there, upon that long-held bastion, I served communion to Helen at the bottom of the stairs, re-establishing the proper stance for the equality of women.

Women don’t need to be only deacons! They are already priests.

I knew that serving communion in the Vatican was destiny for me. All my ministry life has been involved with equity of gender and race. The unity of the Church can only come from a diversity of gifts that work together.

Through the Broken Glass

It has been extremely exciting to watch the progress of women’s freedoms! We see many restrictions gradually improving, and some women have regained full leadership. But more and more must come forward.

That stained-glass ceiling of religion that has kept most of us from full service is broken. How do we pass through it? We press through the shattered shards: not with defensive arguments, not with a chip on our shoulder, but with TRUTH that responds to the Lord’s direction through Love.

It’s Indisputably Clear
  • The Holy Spirit doesn’t manifest His power differently because of the gender of the preacher.
  • Women don’t just minister in God’s permissive will, but in God’s perfect will.
  • Astounding works of the Spirit have come through men, women, and children.
  • If the Holy Spirit doesn’t distinguish gender, race, class, or age, then why should we?

Both men and women must consciously strive to overcome ingrained attitudes that have led to distance and distrust. That’s why our goal shouldn’t be to convince others that we’re gifted or called. We must know who we are, and just be that person.

We can’t “call” ourselves, or grapple for recognition. Only God enables. We aren’t set apart just to challenge the system or merely to debate rights. We must get that chip off our shoulder and be filled with the fruit of the Spirit. We can’t let our culture or society keep us from our calling.

Even though Jesus knew that a prophet wasn’t recognized in his own hometown, He continued to declare the Gospel there. You might not be accepted either, but God’s Presence invades the work that springs from obedience.

“But His word was in mine heart as a burning fire shut up in my bones, and I was weary with forbearing, and I could not stay.”Jeremiah 20:9

If He’s in your blood, if you (male or female) wake and sleep to serve Him, you’re targeted for miracles!

Read more in Dr. Kluane’s books on women and equality at kluane.com/store.

Was this a blessing to you? Thank you for sowing into reform!

♥ DonateMore ArticlesGet the Newsletter